Beware the Media Hype on Vancouver Real Estate
Saturday, October 25th, 2008We are currently being bombarded by news reports that claim the sky is falling on Vancouver real estate. I think that we need to take all of this with a grain of salt. It’s important to realize that the media tends to jump on the bandwagon and overexaggerate trends in either direction. When things are good, they pump them up and inflate them out of proportion with the fundamentals. Likewise, when things are bad the pessimism and fearmongering keep people focused on the news.
However, what I hadn’t realized and what I wanted to draw to the attention of my readers was the mistruths that are espoused by the media. On Thursday evening, there was a news report on Global TV’s New Hour on the Vancouver real estate market. It’s available still online right here. In this one Global TV newsclip by Ted Chernecki there were two major points that were presented as fact but which are entirely untrue.
The primary news that motivated the piece was an economic forecast for the Greater Vancouver real estate market written by Helmut Pastrick of Central 1 Credit Union (while it’s been talked about in the media, I can’t find a link to it online but here’s their website). Pastrick’s prediction was that we’d see a 13% decline in prices in 2009, and 5% in 2010 before the market recovered (not to mention the 12% reduction we’ve already seen since March of this year).
So far so good? Leaving aside the accuracy or usefulness of predictions (and the BCREA will be releasing their own prediction this coming week), what I have a problem with was how the particular Global TV news piece interpreted that press release. Chernecki gave an example of a $1.5 Million home put on the market two days ago. If the predictions were accurate, this home would be worth 30% less in two and a half years and be worth only $1 Million in 2010.
Right? Wrong. We’ve already seen a 12% drop in average prices in Greater Vancouver. That would mean between today and 2010, Pastrick is predicting a further 18% drop in the market. Thus, the $1.5 million home would be worth $1.27 million and NOT $1 million as Ted Chernecki claims.
Secondly, the statistics that are quoted in the news clip are completely false. They claim that in the city of Vancouver there were a total of 2,000 listings and 68 sales. These numbers match no real data that I can find. The facts are that there were 2130 new listings, 6095 total listings and 464 sales in Vancouver East and Vancouver West in the month of September 2008. You can follow the link to read my blog post on the September 2008 Vancouver real estate statistics.
What do you think?
If you are interested in the truth, and would like to see the numbers reported with accuracy and honesty then you can follow my Vancouver real estate blog. I report on the monthly statistics released by the Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver, as well as my own weekly reporting of the numbers for Vancouver East and Vancouver West.
If you are thinking of buying or selling, or just have questions, contact me here or send me a quick email.
Copyright © 2008 by Sebastian Albrecht, Vancouver Realtor with Royal LePage Westside ”Beware the Media Hype on Vancouver Real Estate”
|
|
|
|
|
|
Photo from CBC


